Freezing in the Sun

The air conditioning in a tanning salon had not worked correctly all summer. That was not good: Tanning customers want to look like they have spent all day at the beach, not like they have sweated it out in a sauna.

Article Tools

“Oh, and one thing more,” the salon manager said. “We had a flood in here a couple of weeks ago, and we had to turn the air conditioning off altogether since then.”

I quickly figured that the flood was caused by a split U-bend in the hot-water heating coil in the salon's small air handler. The only time water coils split like that is when they freeze. Freezing cold air flowing over a coil will freeze the water in the two adjacent tubes, trapping unfrozen water in the U-shaped bend that connects the tubes. When the water in the tubes freezes, it expands. However, no space is available to absorb the expansion. Tremendous pressure builds up, and the U-bend splits open. But this was October — the weather had not yet been nearly cold enough to freeze a coil.

“Well,” I thought, “I'll have to figure out why that coil split, but, meanwhile, these people need air conditioning, and a split heating coil is no reason to shut off the air conditioning completely.”

So, I turned the air conditioning back on, but nothing happened. Was it the thermostat? The wiring? The controls? (The HVAC system was a high-efficiency system. With a two-speed air-conditioning compressor, variable-speed fan control, and a zone control system, the tangle of controls wiring looked like something out of “Star Wars.”)

As I sat in front of the unit tracing wiring and poring over the controls schematics, I felt a slight cool breeze coming through the open door of the fan section.

“It must be outdoor air coming in,” I thought, as I concentrated on the wiring schematics. However, the longer I sat, the colder and stronger the breeze felt. I suddenly realized what had happened: The air conditioning was working fine; it was the fan motor that had failed.

The air conditioning cooled the air-conditioning coil, which was right on top of the hot-water coil. With no fan to circulate the cooling, the air-conditioning coil got very cold — icy cold, in fact. So much cold air dropped down from the air-conditioning coil and flowed over the hot-water coil that it froze the water inside of the hot-water coil. That explained the other mystery, too. The air conditioning had not worked very well that summer because the fan had not been running.

Have a “war story” to share? Send it to Executive Editor Scott Arnold at scott.arnold@penton.com. Authors are paid $50 per published war story.


Acceptable Use Policy
blog comments powered by Disqus

Follow us on

Mike Weil Scott Arnold

HPAC Engineering eNewsletters

Marketplace

Recent Comments

Powered by Disqus
Innovative Solutions

Product Reviews of some of the best new HVACR technology...

Best of 2011!


Here are HPAC Engineering's top articles of 2011.
Click here to see if your favorites made the list!

Back to Top

Browse Back Issues

May 20121

April 2012

March 2012

February 2012

January 2012

December 2011